As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from amazon.com

Blackmagic Video Help vs Atomos Ninja V – Which One is Proper for You?


If you’re taking pictures video it is best to decide up a monitor. It’s principally a vital buy and these days when you go for a monitor/recorder combo you’ll be able to unlock uncooked video with a number of the newest mirrorless cameras. For that there are solely two corporations try to be taking a look at: Atomos and Blackmagic.

Atomos shook issues up when ProRes RAW and Ninja V got here out and tons of cameras began supporting it. Then Blackmagic with the Video Help made Blackmagic RAW an possibility. Some cameras even help each, just like the FUJIFILM X-H2S. Josh Cameron needs that will help you decide the very best one when you simply want a monitor or are in search of uncooked seize.

When contemplating the codecs the choice is sort of made for you. ProRes RAW is supported finest by Ultimate Lower Professional X and Blackmagic RAW is designed for DaVinci Resolve. That’s a effective method to decide however there are nuances to all of it.

Clearly, it is best to care concerning the codec choices. 

For the Ninja V:

  • ProRes
  • DNx
  • H.265
  • ProRes RAW

For the Blackmagic Video Help:

  • ProRes
  • DNx
  • Blackmagic RAW

Good choices for each, although the Atomos might need an edge in case you are in search of H.265, which you in all probability aren’t in case you are utilizing these units.

Trying on the menus, Blackmagic’s intuitive touchscreen interface is way, a lot better for the consumer than Atomos. It’s powerful to seek out some settings on the Ninja V in comparison with the Video Help.

Picture Credit score: Atomos

One challenge for each was the colour accuracy out of the field. Blackmagic was capable of be tweaked to one thing first rate whereas Atomos required the Ninja to be despatched again for a recalibration. Atomos does have higher recording indicators.

It even has the total pink report body whereas Blackmagic solely has some smaller tally lights that aren’t as apparent.

Media is an fascinating comparability as they select wildly completely different strategies. Atomos has the choice of utilizing commonplace SATA SSDs of their enclosures or choosing up devoted SSDminis.

Blackmagic alternatively affords SD playing cards or direct recording through USB-C to a conveyable drive. Except you might have some rigging for the SSDs on the Blackmagic it truthfully might be best to only decide up SATA SSDs and set up them in some caddies. These can simply be plugged into computer systems with a easy adapter.

Picture Credit score: Blackmagic Design

Blackmagic does win on I/O because it has full SDI in/out alongside the HDMI in/out. There’s additionally a 12V energy enter immediately on the physique. The Ninja V doesn’t have SDI, solely HDMI, and for a 12V enter you want a battery adapter.

Additionally, the Ninja energy button isn’t as nicely designed as you’ll hope. Blackmagic isn’t excellent as there is a matter with the USB-C port being positioned proper subsequent to the center backside 1/4”-20 mounting thread.

Total you’ll be able to’t go incorrect with both. Atomos could also be higher when you don’t ever plan on utilizing Blackmagic RAW, particularly since it’s cheaper. Nonetheless, Blackmagic appears to supply a extra full package deal out of the field with SDI, USB-C, and 12V energy enter.

Which might you decide?

[source: Josh Cameron]

Order Hyperlinks:

  • Blackmagic Design Video Help 5” (B&H, Amazon)
  • Atomos Ninja V 5” Monitor/Recorder (B&H, Amazon)

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Interestity
Logo
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart